Tuesday, February 12, 2013

3D Printing–Potential Disadvantages

Dear Class,

Three-dimensional printing progressed from academic curiosity to powerful production tool through the 1980s and 1990s. The apparatus works by injecting media onto a bed, sometimes submerged in liquid, in thin layers, usually around 100 micrometers. After repeating this process many thousands of times, a physical model of a digital object is produced in three dimensions.

As with most technologies, three-dimensional printing has the potential to be socially disruptive. For instance, how will we, as a society, decide to protect the intellectual property rights of companies whose products are likely to be copied using three-dimensional printing? (See this article on how three-dimensional printing is likely to disrupt tabletop gaming company, Games Workshop.) How will we choose to regulate the production of certain objects, like assault rifles? (For more information about weapons manufacture using three-dimensional printing, see this interview with Defense Distributed founder Cody Wilson.)

As technology is adopted, there is the tendency for our lives to be lived farther and farther from the physical. Three-dimensional printing is an odd reversal of this trend, a movement of the digital world into the physical. And yet, the physical experience of three-dimensional printing is not the same as other acts of creation. The designer of objects for three-dimensional printing never knows the human pleasure of craftsmanship, the tactile experience of exploring material as it progresses from imagination to form.

The craftsman knows the sensory delights of working in the physical world: the sound and smell of wood as the plane removes shavings, the touch of the plane, the sight of wood taking its final form.
(Image Source.)

With best wishes for your happiness,

Hayden

3 comments:

  1. Although I think that this 3D printing technology is remarkable in its capabilities, I can't help but agree with Hayden's side of the argument.
    3D printing may help us do amazing things in the medical field, but if available to the public, I believe more harm than good would follow.

    In her book The Proust and the Squid, Wolf writes "It would be a shame if brilliant technology were to end up threatening the kind of intellect that produced it" (22). I think that 3D technology might aid in Wolf's greatest fear. If this printing technique was in widespread use, society would become very dependent on the printers and we would lose the beauty of craftsmanship in manmade objects and the knowledge of how to make them. Also, the cost of the printers is another major flaw. I am fully supportive of the use of 3D printers in the medical field, but I am opposed to their widespread public use.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I feel this technology is not the most promising. The medical applications seemed minimal to me as organ growing is already possible through pluripotent stem cells grown on plastic scaffolding. As I read through the Carr book this week, I discover how different aspects on life are responsible for the stimulation of different parts of the brain and the subsequent strengthening of the neuroplastic junctions. I find this to be pertinent to Hayden's point about handcrafted goods. I feel that without some of the craftmanship that comes from making things, such as cooking, sewing, or simple things that we do everyday, the junctions will weaken in our brain and will fill with the work we now process, such as computer techniques. This reminds me of the "Renaissance Man" figure that was desired in the past, as a well-rounded person would have more strengthened junctions between the different parts of the brain and I believe that increased connectivity between all aspects of life will increase understanding and progress in the various aspects of everyday life.
    -Carr "The Shallows" (34)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I do not have much to state directly, I just stumbled across this article and wished to share it:

    http://www.news.com.au/technology/patient-has-75-per-cent-of-his-skull-replaced-by-3dd-printed-implant/story-e6frfro0-1226593075470

    Sorry it will not post as a hyperlink, but anyone should be able to copy and paste the url.

    ReplyDelete