We discussed Post-Marxism and defined it for the class. We
then began a discussion in the class talking about the different technologies
and whether or not they fit with the Marxist or post-Marxist concepts.
Technologies we talked about included google glass, golden-I, and arduino.
Classical Marxism and the Frankfurt School:
Classical Marxism is not what
most people think. Marx says, “The
Mode of Production of material life conditions the social, political, and
intellectual life process in general.”
To understand this we must understand the relationship between base and
superstructure.
Base – Forces of production (raw materials, tools, workers, etc.) and
the relations of production (slavery: master/slave, feudal: lord/peasant,
capitalist: bourgeois/proletariat)
Bourgeiois – “of or characteristic of the middle class, typically with reference
to its perceived materialistic values or conventional attitudes”
Proletariat
– “workers or working-class people, regarded collectively (often used with
reference to Marxism)”
Superstructure – consists of institutions (political, educational,
cultural) and forms of social consciousness (political, philosophical, and
cultural) generated by these institutions
The relationship between the base and superstructure is said to be
twofold because the superstructure expresses the base, but the base conditions
or determines the superstructure.
“The ideas of the ruling class are…the ruling ideas; the
class ruling material force in society is..the…ruling intellectual force.” This does NOT mean the ideas of the
ruling class are meant to be imposed on subordinate classes! “A ruling class is compelled…to
represent its interest as the common interest of all the members of society…to
give its ideas the form of universality, and represent them as the only
rational, universally valid ones.”
The Frankfurt School is the name given to a group of German
intellectuals associated with the University of Frankfurt. I see their ideas as a type of applied
Marxism; that is, what happens when you take Marxism off paper and apply it to
real life.
Critical Theory – the name given to the institute’s critical
mix of Marxism and psychoanalysis
The main difference between Classical Marxism and the
Frankfurt School is seen through comparing the above quotes with the following:
“The Frankfurt School see only ‘conformity’: a situation in which ‘the deceived
masses’ are caught in a ‘circle of manipulation and retroactive need in which
the unity of the system grows ever stronger.”
Althusserianism and Hegemony:
Althusserianism is a version of
Marxism that was developed by Thomas Althusser. Rejecting the base/superstructure concepts of Marxism,
Althusserians focus on social formation, referred to as the structure in
dominance. The belief behind
structure in dominance is that large social practices are the result of the
economy. For example, we are all
students at LSU because jobs have become scarcer and we
want to be able to compete for them.
Althusser has two types of
interpretation: Symptomatic Interpretation and Identifying people as members of
a group. The Symptomatic Interpretation focuses on identifying a
problematic. The problematic is a
term coined by Marx during his critique of Adam Smith’s work. Marx believed Adam Smith was addressing
a problem by providing a solution, without the question being posed. An example of and Althusserian
problematic would be a typical car commercial. Most car advertisements focus a car driving quickly on an
empty road near an ocean, canyon, or mountain with the ending addressing the
gas mileage and cost. The problematic
in this type of media would have several meanings
1)
Because the car is driving on an empty road, a
buyer will never be stuck in traffic in this car
2)
Because the car is driving through a scenic
route, the car and nature can coexist, without the car causing any harm to the
environment. This is also
emphasized through the listing of the gas mileage.
3)
Because the car is “only $25,000”, the extra
excluded costs of gas and insurance will not effect the buyer’s decision to get
the car.
Although the problematic in this
example is deceiving to the buyer, it helps the car sell. Machery was an
Althusserian who believed in relating the problematic to a historical
event. For example, the movie The
Shining, Althusser would say the problematic is identifying the connection
between mental illness and murder because of the insanity Jack develops. Machery on the other hand would say
that The Shining is addressing the problems of racism, specifically the terror
inflicted on the Native Americans when the white man inhabited the United
States due to constant tribal symbols placed in the movie, and the only victim
of murder is Black.
The interpretation of Althusser
does not seem to be affective.
Althusser would group people by social beliefs, and address them through
their beliefs. An example of
why this is ineffective would be the social issue of racism. If a person claimed to be opposed to
racism but laughs at a racist joke, Althusser could not group that individual
by that belief. This interpretation has been seen to effective in the media
through advertising. Most
commercials address people by saying things like “This product is perfect for
you!” “Do you travel a lot? Then you should buy this!” By identifying people in
groups, Advertisement can reach a wide range of people.
Hegemony is a type of democratic
government in which the dominant group leads the inferior group intellectually
and morally. This belief is how
Marxists explain the success of capitalistic democracies. Hegemony only works if every individual
in the society is concerned with his or her own success. For example, in the previous political
election, republicans would have typically voted for Mitt Romney, rather than
democratic nominee, Barrack Obama.
Hegemony is not only incorporated into government, but also in pop
culture. A good example of this
would be Justin Bieber. Not
everyone likes Justin Bieber’s music, but nearly everyone knows who he is and
has heard his music. In this
situation, it is in everyone’s best interest to know that Justin Bieber is
successful pop star, in the social aspect. But not everyone is going to go buy and listen to his music.